Bortolazzi would be proud.
Eugene C. Braig IV | Columbus, OH United States | 09/12/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"The orchestral works are beautifully performed and recorded, but, as I regard much of Hummel's purely orchestral output, not particularly memorable. I do like the nod to popular music in the Freudenfest Overture.
Where this recording truly shines is in the concerti. Every part is crisply defined. The balance between orchestra and soloists is perfect. This is as good a recording of the sprightly trumpet concerto as I've ever heard. While the differences are evident, I believe this newly discovered version of the mandolin concerto would require a very critical listen by a familiar aficionado to aurally differentiate from the published version. How many would discern that this reaches a half tone or so higher than the typical mandolin of Hummel's day? Bortolazzi played the rather obscure Cremonese mandolin and I'd be interested to know if this revision was intended for him or somebody with a standard Neapolitan instrument tucked neatly under arm.
I confess my great admiration for Alison Stephens. Of all the professional classical mandolinists recording today, she may make the least effort to dazzle through pyrotechnics. However, she manages to dazzle more than most through her disciplined, infallible technique and crisp clear tone. This is as much beauty as can be squeezed out of a mandolin and Ms. Stephens' squeezin' is effortless."
Hummel concertos
A. J. Millington | Kapiti Coast, New Zealand | 09/30/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I have both these concertos on CD but these two new recordings show them in a new light. The new parts to the Mandolin concerto fit in well and improve the flow and musicallity of the piece. The trumpet concerto is played slower and more gently than Hakon Hardenbergers version that I already have, I feel this improves the concerto. I am pleased with the CD.
Tony Hummel fan"