A surprising composer
Lauro Machado Coelho | São Paulo, São Paulo Brazil | 09/08/2002
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Rott, Bruckner's pupil, wrote only one symphony at age 20 and died insane 26 years old. He was a precocious genius who lacked recognition (Brahms said his music was vulgar). This E major Symphony is distinctly pre-mahlerian -- its Scherzo has all the typical features of a burlesque Mahler scherzo. The sheer beauty of Rott's music, its force of persuasion makes us regret the fact that his talent could not develop -- the History of Music loses a lot with his sad fate and untimely death."
Late Romantic Excess In All Its Blazing Glory
Goldbaker | 11/25/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Wandered into this one a few days ago totally at random. I had never heard of the composer, conductor, or orchestra. I can't stop listening to it. After two decades of going through Mahler, R. Strauss, and Bruckner over and over again, I finally found something new.
Apparently, this was written in 1880 when the composer was 22. It predates anything by Mahler and Richard Strauss. Brahms only had two symphonies done at this time, and Bruckner had not yet written his great symphony in E major (the 7th). While the Wagner and Bruckner influences are clear, this piece has a voice all its own. Mahler must have been well aware of it -- the similarities are striking. Neither the composition or recording are perfect, but Mr. Segerstam and the orchestra provide an all-out performance that is genuinely thrilling."