Performed with a freshness and vitality that is unmatched
03/30/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"It is no wonder that Classic CD, the definitive English publication, rated this recording the best of all -- yes, all -- the recordings of the Messiah. The clarity of tone, the vibrancy and vitality of the orchestra, the superb chorus (something for which Boston Baroque is particularly known), and the outstanding soloists make this a recording that is unmatched. When it was released, it was nominated for a Grammy as the best choral work of the year, as was Boston Baroque's recent recording of Monteverdi's Vespers."
Hallelujah! - The Recording to Have.
D. Seymour | Atlanta, GA USA | 06/16/2002
(5 out of 5 stars)
"If I could own only one version of the Messiah, this would be it! Other copies I own emphasize either lyricism and spirituality or pomp and grandeur. But only with Pearlman and the Boston Baroque does Handel's masterpiece POP! The period instruments are feather light and the period tempi are lightning quick. The chorus is small & intimate but precise and powerful. They deliver the most tender 'And He shall purify' which culminates in perfect jubilation. The soloists are stellar! The soprano part can often be a let-down in the Messiah. Not so here. Karen Clift, as Anna Russell would say, has a pure, clear blue, nymphs and shepherds tone that floats through her solos like a silver lining. I cannot say enough about mezzo-soprano, Catherine Robbin, who possesses a fascinating (dare I say) coloratura technique that fixes me every time I hear her. Tenor, Bruce Fowler is magnificently effortless. Victor Ledbetter brings his equally irresistible, ringing baritone into play to round out the perfect cast. The success of this recording, above all else, is the blend. The orchestra, chorus and soloists are balanced seamlessly. You have aural access to everyone as if they were performing in your own living room. The chamber proportions have an intensity that larger, modern ensembles simply cannot match. The Messiah's intricate beauty is never lost in the shuffle or masked by the chorus. This recording is a unified whole: delicate, satisfying, fun and damn near incredible. Handel would be proud!"
THE Messiah
Joanna Daneman | Middletown, DE USA | 12/26/2002
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Yes, it is "Messiah", not "The Messiah" that is the title of this great work of music. But this recording is "the" Messiah recording to have. Hands down. I think I've sung this work in various choirs over 20 times. And I have had many recordings, Baroque-style, full orchestral, you name it. But this recording is still my favorite. In particular, the "Air: He shall feed His flock like a shepherd" sung by both Clift and mezzo Catherine Robbin was what decided me that this was THE one.There is no sample here of that section of the work so you will have to trust me on this one; if you love "Messiah" this is one recording that does it full justice."
Best Recording of
Walter Fekula | New York, NY USA | 10/05/2002
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Several weeks ago attended a concert in which Karen Clift sang beautifully. I immediately fell in love with her and her creamy, luscious coloratura, lyric soprano voice. When I got home, I punched in "Clift" into Amazon and this recording popped up. What a sensational recording. Miss Clift is superb. The other soloists:Catherine Robbin, Bruce Fowler and Victor Ledbetter are also excellent. The Boston Baroque Orchestra & Chorus, under the Direction of Martin Pearlman plays and sings splendidly. A wonderful performance all around. A very well-balanced recording. Hats off to Telarc. I have other "Messiah" recordings. None measure up to this one."
This Deserves Six Stars
Teop Tnomrev | Vermont, USA | 11/30/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"How to communicate what makes this the best of all recordings?This is the most "song-like" of any of the available perfermances. Where other performances present this work as an ORATORIO [Yes, all capital], with abdominally operatic fervor, with soloists belting out their hosanas (which has its place I suppose), this is the performance that captures the lilting, song-like, innocently joyful qualities of this great work. The sound is clear (thanks to superb mic placement) and the playing is lucid without being strident. All in all, Pearlman brings out a song-like lightness to this oratorio that makes it glow & sparkle. Indeed, Pearlman, in his liner notes, stresses that this was partly his aim--an attempt to capture the speach-like singing which he believes was more typical of Handel's era.One can disagree with whether this is what Handel intended, but then that's a dead-end question in certain ways... though it's fun to speculate. Handel was a showman and liked nothing more than to please the crowd and line his purse with the praise. Nothing wrong in this. If he were alive today, he would probably make a bee-line for the Morman Tabernacle choir. In his own day, reports have it that when Handel could really get his way, his choruses were huge and his orchrestras loud and many.Pearlman's forces are not huge. I'll take Pearlman's Handel."