B. J. Miceli | Boston, MA United States | 07/28/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Having heard this recording probably 100 times, I can confidently recommend it to anyone interested in hearing Sutherland in the role which earned her the sobriquet "La Stupenda" from Italian audiences in the 1960's. Her voice is astonishingly powerful and agile. Furthermore, Sutherland's natural grandeur and command make the sorceress Alcina appropriately larger than life. Importantly, she and the rest of the cast sing out in vivid, colorful voices far removed from the anemic "period" sound heard so often today. Granted, the score is cut and Renee Fleming also sings a glamourous and gorgeous Alcina (complete) on CD, but her liberal use of portamento and rubato and her fruity vibrato are more appropriate to Bellini than Handel (but the smudgy coloratura is wrong for both!). By contrast, Sutherland avoids these devices, singing with real Baroque style (even if her diction is a little muddy at times!)which balances Italianate warmth with technical precision. This is one of Sutherland's best recordings and serves Handel's music well."
Ravishing tones and singing
B. J. Miceli | 07/05/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"The magnitude of singing in this Alcina is second to none. The Joan Sutherland here is a young one. And we all know her what a phenomenal singer she was before Esclamonde(1974) destroyed her voice. Here, in 1960 something, it is the most glowing, sumptuous, just simply gorgeous soprano to ever come out of a person's mouth. It is as silvery and clear as it can be. And the squillo is in full force.
Yep, it's all here, the amazing coloratura, the celebrated upper register to the full voice high E, and the awesome accuracy of pitch. No wonder they call her the "Voice of the Century".
Freni is here, and she is lovely. I bet you've never heard her sound like that. She's no Sutherland. But she's definitely at least as good a lyric soprano as Price or Caballe.
A greatly underrated recording. The music is glorious. In my opinion, it is as good as the other great Handel opera Julius Caesar. I hope I spelled it right. If you love Baroque, it doesn't get any better than this."
Beautiful
B. J. Miceli | 12/31/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"A stellar cast heading by the supreme artist, Joan Sutherland. She had, indeed, the most beautiful soprano during her youth. With a supporting cast such as this, how can this Alcina lose? Of these great artists, next to Sutherland, Freni is the most lovely. All in all, fantastic singing of some of the most beautiful music that Handel ever wrote."
Excellent inauthentic recording of Alcina
Michel | 06/17/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This opera is filled with exquisite music. Handel wrote a truly beautiful opera. All the roles are cast from strength, and each singer delivers his or her arias with coloratura fluency and dramatic commitment. The surprise here was Joan Sutherland, who sings a ravishingly beautiful and dramatically involved Alcina. While her diction is clear in the recitatives, it turns into mush during the arias. Her voice is so beautiful, just the pure sound of it, the warmest golden velvet, is balm to one's ears. Teresa Berganza shows off her much smaller, but quite beautiful voice. Her Ruggiero is excellently sung with superb diction and great coloratura. I was amazed at her breath control during the florid sections of "Sta nell'Ircana". Monica Sinclair is a wonderful Bradamante. Sutherland, Berganza, and Sinclair deliver an excellent Act 3 trio. Luigi Alva is very good as Oronte, but his runs aren't as clean as the ladies'. In the small role of Oberto, Mirella Freni shows off her gorgeous voice and excellent coloratura. She is just adorable. Graziella Sciutti is a great Morgana. Richard Bonynge does a fine job of conducting and the playing of the London Symphony Orchestra is simply superb.The arias from "Giulio Cesare" attached to the third CD are wonderful delights, though you will find dramatic commitment lacking in Sutherland's singing of Cleopatra's arias. The singing itself is great, but the drama is just not there."
Magical Alcina
Michel | Montreal, Quebec | 05/04/2003
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Despite being cut and tampered with and by today's standard
grossly inauthentic this 1962 recoding of Alcina remains a very
attractive option. Joan Sutherland is caught here at her vocal
zenith - producing ravishing sound and easily dominating over
ensembles. The rest of the cast is excellent with special men-
tion to Tereza Berganza and Mirella Freni both very young and
singing superbly. Very well recorded and briskly conducted by
Richard Bonynge - this set should not dissapoint any lover of
beautiful singing and music. As a fill-up on the third cd we
have excerpts of Giulio Cesare with Sutherland/Horne/Sinclair/