A disappointing dud
Osvaldo Colarusso | 12/19/1999
(1 out of 5 stars)
"I have found Levine's Mahler to be of interest, but this is by far his weakest performance. Both singers are too operatic for this music, and the orchestral backing is lifeless. Avoid this one."
A powerful performance
Osvaldo Colarusso | 01/13/2001
(4 out of 5 stars)
"From the opening bars, Siegfried Jerusalem electrifies the listener. I found his performance absolutely magnificent, and it alone makes this CD worth having; yet by no means does Jessye Norman fail to hold up her end. Her voice is rich and lovely, and complements Jerusalem very well.I gather some have found Levine's conducting unsatisfactory; I found his tempi energetic and well balanced; certainly nothing to complain about, even if his interpretation does not stand out among his peers. But in any case, it's the singers that make this recording exceptional. I recommend it highly."
One fantastic recording
Osvaldo Colarusso | Curitiba, Paraná Brazil | 05/16/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Das Lied von der Erde was always, since the time of Bruno Walter. abundantly recorded. Three great mezzos and one baritone are notable in this story: Kathleen Ferrier, Christa Ludwig, Jessye Norman and Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau.Ferrier recorded with Walter ( the first conductor of the work), Ludwig recorded with Klemperer (fantastic) and Karajan, and recorded on DVD with Bernstein, and Bernstein was also the conductor of Dieskau. Jessye Norman, unfortunately ,in her most famous recording of the work, sang with Colin Davis, in a very uninspired moment. Fortunately we have this forgot CD , when Mrs Norman sang with one fantastic conductor, James Levine.Levine is in general slow but very profound. The Orchestra sounds ( as ever)perfect, and I would know the names of the first flute, the first oboe and the first clarinet. The solos, specially in the last song are very beautiful.
The tenor part is too excellent hear .Mr Jerusalem , one of the best wagnerian tenor of his generation, sings , specially the first song in a fantastic way, with special attention to the accents.Far better than Patzak and Vickers ( one excellent singer, but recorded the work too old) .The only rival to Mr Jerusalem is Wunderlich.
I can't understand why Deutsche Grammophon hides this CD. Is by far superior of the recordings of Boulez and Giulini."