Search - Great Jazz Trio :: Collaboration

Far More Than Alternate Takes

Stephen A. Smith | Boston, MA | 05/17/2005

(5 out of 5 stars)

"This disc is a companion to "Autumn Leaves" and "Someday My Prince Will Come." All three CDs feature material recorded on May 12 and 13, 2002 by the trio of Hank Jones (piano), Richard Davis (bass), and Elvin Jones (drums). "Collaboration" features alternate takes of tunes that were variously presented on the first two discs, plus a solo piano rendition of Eubie Blake's "Memories of You."



If you've heard either of the previous discs, there isn't much to say. If you haven't, you should order all three immediately. This is jazz at its best -- or, more accurately, at its finest. These guys have more than two centuries' experience between them, and they know how to get it done. If you like jazz, you'll love this music; and if you don't like this music, you probably won't like jazz.



The CD is accompanied by an essay that Hank wrote on May 28, 2004, ten days after his younger brother Elvin passed away. These few hundred words are among the most heartfelt and touching I've ever read. I'm saddened by Hank's loss, but I admire his bravery in sharing his feelings with millions of fans. And ultimately, I'm grateful for the chance to hear the music this trio created together."

Long live the Great Elvin Jones!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

J. Bewley | San Diego, CA | 05/14/2005

(5 out of 5 stars)

"When Elvin touched the drums, he made works of art. There is no hint of discarded takes or unexceptable work here; everyone is in top form. I can't help but think of Elvin's dedication to his craft that clearly is on display here. The fire, the sensitivity, and color made us all think deeply about what is possibile in playing this instrument.



Long live the great drummer, and human being -Elvin Jones.



jb"

If you are interested in the technical side of drumming...

Eric J. Anderson | Ankeny, Iowa | 05/10/2009

(4 out of 5 stars)

"As a casual listener, I had difficulty getting into this album, or at least I had difficulty with the drum solos, which were difficult to follow. I'm not a drummer. I enjoy many other kinds of jazz, and in fact I enjoy the albums that preceded this "collaboration" with the same participants.



I'd say Elvin Jones stretches out and does his own thing a lot more on this CD than the others. This might be very instructive and entertaining for drummers and jazz technicians. For me, not so much. I don't fault the playing ability or even the interpretations here. I'm only saying that I didn't find them as enjoyable as other Great Jazz Trio outings."