"1980 was the last year I saw the Grateful Dead. The two shows I caught in Springfield, MA and New Haven, CT that year were underwhelming. The Spingfield show was embarassing, with Garcia flubbing lyrics, forgetting lyrics, stumbling through solos, and stumbling on the stage. The following night in New Haven was "ok" ,with Phil saving the evening. But still, pretty bland and slow. So I was surprised when a friend lent me this two CD set. Somebody must have brewed up a batch of double expresso for the band on these two nights, because these performances really move. The songs from "Go To Heaven" get a kick in the ass, and the "Althea" is the best that I've heard. The one critisism I have is Brent's keyboard sound. That Fender-Rhodes sounds like a door-bell. Otherwise, this set is a pleasant surprise and worth adding to your collection."
Worth a listen
Ricky Steamboat | Connecticut | 10/02/2005
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I actually enjoy a lot of the 1979-1981 period. Yes, a lot of the freeform exploratory jamming of the 1977-78 period is not there. But there are some good crisp shows from this period. Brent has not come into his own yet but he is a welcome addition to the fold after the way Keith played(or I should say not played) during the 1976-79 period. His vocal harmonies are a welcome change as well. Let's face it, Donna's live vocal harmonies were atrocious. This show is good, not great. It will not blow your mind by any stretch. The sound quality is very good and it has some good moments. A lot of people were bashing 1980 as a horrible year, it had some great moments too. Let's not forget the Warfield/Radio City run. 1982-1984 were some horrible years. Talk about uninspired playing. Yikes. Jerry was such a mess during those years it is painful to listen to. His health wasn't much better during 1985 but the shows got better. Has anyone ever noticed (or is it just me) that during the 1983-1986 period there are very few pictures of Garcia taken. If you look at say an old Relix from that period they will have a lot of pictures of the rest of the band and very few of Garcia. It's almost as if they were trying to protect him by omitting his pictures. There was no denying the guy was a complete mess. Look at the cover of the book Playing in the Band by David Gans. You can actually see all the soot and residue of the tips of his fingers from the heroin that he was smoking. All in all this CD is worthwhile to have in your collection if you're a head. The Nassau from 1981 that became a Dick's Picks is much better show from this period."
Grateful Dead rocks Nassau
Shadowgraphs | 06/07/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This album has not left my cd player in months. It is simply amazing. Although I am a big fan of the earlier dead recordings, my favorite era of the dead is the late seventies, early eighties shows, when their catalog of tunes was getting huge. With this release, there is no sense in buying their studio album Go To Heaven, as it takes all the notable tracks and improves them greatly. This is a mostly Bob Weir album with stellar versions of Lightning-Supplication, Sailor-Circumstance, and Althea. Not to mention a slightly rare Peggy-O. This album is unbelievable and I HIGHLY reccomend it to anyone!"
Underrated Dead
Adam Jensen | Kitchener, Ontario, Canada | 03/12/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"People seem to have two problems with this album: it's not a complete show, and it's from 1980 (many people say "There is no good Grateful Dead after year x"). First, while it is not one full show, it flows nicely and has the feel of a show. Second, there is good to be found in every year of the Grateful Dead's career. I'll agree the later years were far less kind to them than the earlier, but in 1980 they were still rockin out just fine. If you're wary because "Dead Set" is also from '80 and you're not happy with it, know that this album has something that one lacks: it's brimming with energy. The Jack Straw>Franklin's Tower is great, the China Cat Sunflower>I Know You Rider is one of my favourite versions, and the run on the second disc from Playing in the Band to Good Lovin' is like the Dead of old. Give this a chance, and I don't think you'll be disappointed.
Edit of this review(5/18/05): After owning this album for a while and listening to it more, I feel that my original review, while accurate, was a bit generous. I would now give the album four stars instead of five (I'd change it, but I don't know how). There is some filler or songs that sound kind of cheesy, such as Far From Me and Lazy Lightnin' (although the Supplication jam is very good). In all, this is still a great album with the highlights for me being the ones I originally mentioned, but it's not perfect."