George Winston cites the Doors as a seminal influence on his music in the liner notes for the 20th anniversary edition of Autumn. Winston is a voracious musical explorer, and the Doors are among several musical tributes Wi... more »nston has rolling around in his head. He's already paid homage to pianist Vince Guaraldi with Linus and Lucy. Winston's take on the acid-rock shamans is sometimes magical, sometimes regretful. It's no secret that George isn't a great technician, and you can hear the flaws whenever he remains true to the melody, especially replicating Robbie Krieger's guitar lines. But some songs are just perfect for Winston, notably "Crystal Ship," which he expands into a gorgeous meditation. Winston mixes the hits, including "Light My Fire," with some eccentric personal choices like "Spanish Caravan" and "My Wild Love." Ardent Doors devotees may cringe, but Winston fans will find a home here. --John Diliberto« less
George Winston cites the Doors as a seminal influence on his music in the liner notes for the 20th anniversary edition of Autumn. Winston is a voracious musical explorer, and the Doors are among several musical tributes Winston has rolling around in his head. He's already paid homage to pianist Vince Guaraldi with Linus and Lucy. Winston's take on the acid-rock shamans is sometimes magical, sometimes regretful. It's no secret that George isn't a great technician, and you can hear the flaws whenever he remains true to the melody, especially replicating Robbie Krieger's guitar lines. But some songs are just perfect for Winston, notably "Crystal Ship," which he expands into a gorgeous meditation. Winston mixes the hits, including "Light My Fire," with some eccentric personal choices like "Spanish Caravan" and "My Wild Love." Ardent Doors devotees may cringe, but Winston fans will find a home here. --John Diliberto
songs featured: Spanish Caravan; Love Me Two Times; Light My Fire; a nice rendition.
0 of 1 member(s) found this review helpful.
CD Reviews
Stunning and lively with emotion
- Kasia S. | New York City | 07/15/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Honestly I'm not a fan of the Doors, I don't like or dislike them, but they are not something I listen to. My boyfriend however loves them, and I prefer New Age to a lot of music but this cd is something that we can both listen to. I had no idea the first time I heard it that it was a tribute to the Doors, and quite frankly if you love good luscious music then there is no reason no to like this album. I was surprised how much I adored the album, recognizing some of the songs and admiring their new interpretation on the piano. I have always loved the piano, its mahogany coat, the mechanics and inner working, the alabaster and onyx keys, it is a marvel, and even thought I'm a trained flutist, this was my second instrument and I have enjoyed playing it for the past 18 years.
The one song that caught my attention and made me get this cd was The Crystal Ship. Regardless of any influences it sounds like pure George Winston stroking the keys, letting his fingers hit the notes making hair on my body stand straight. The simple, melancholy and staggering melody is haunting; I promise it is something that might never leave ones memory. To me it sounds like a ship with full sails gliding on dark waters in moonlight. People are Strange is wicked, gypsy like and smoky, a divine and hot song really nicely done by Winston. Love Street sounds like a tired loner, laying in bed staring at the ceiling, perhaps smoking a cigarette, pondering life and love. Love me Two Times is jazzy, flirty and funky, its has bluesy undertones and is definitely a nice loud tune. Love Her Madly sounds like a rag time, not my favorite even though I love rag times, but it's a fun song for the Doors fans.
The album is a nice mix of lively and misty moods, a wonderful change in textures and refreshes the listener's palate, may I say, almost like a thirteen course meal where each piece served is different yet it all goes together. Light my Fire for example was done wonderfully, even though it was about fire, it sounded cool, like rain drops dancing on an iron buckets and turned upside down glass jars sitting on an open window still.
Even if I wasn't told about these songs being originally done by the Doors, I would have loved this calming, refreshing, lovely and in places wild album. George Winston has been one of my favorites for a long time, and this belongs in everyone's library. I love reading to this, sometimes getting lost in what I was doing just as now, I didn't plan on writing a review, but I was listening to the music, while hanging out in my room and I was mesmerized tremendously and felt the urge to give it some thumbs up. Lovely lovely lovely!"
A Doors Fan Who Likes The Album
One Listener's Opinion | Sacramento, CA | 05/26/2008
(4 out of 5 stars)
"George Winston doing an album of Doors songs? What sick mind would think of such a thing? Apparently George Winston. And if that isn't strange enough, the album gets the Ray Manzarek Seal of Approval. In fact, the two of them even did a series of concerts together.
I first saw this CD at Tower Records on Watt Avenue in Sacramento. I'm a big Doors fan, but had never really listened to any of Winston's music before. The fact that Ray liked the album coupled with the fact that I always thought of Winston as a New Age artist roused my curiosity. There was a listening station available and this was one of the featured CDs. I listened to a few of the tracks, bought the CD, and give it a solid 4+ star rating.
IMHO, the highlights are People Are Strange, Riders on the Storm, and My Wild Love. Almost all of the songs range from good to excellent. The only clunker (again in my opinion) is Bird of Prey which was never really a Doors song anyway. It was a Jim Morrison demo that was never fully fleshed out, so Winston didn't have that much to work with.
I recommend the album to Doors fans who don't mind having the Doors' music interpreted by other artists. In fact, I'd like to see Winston put out a Volume 2 someday.
"
Winston/Doors CD
K. Knapp | va | 01/09/2007
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This cd is awesome. If you like piano, George Winston is incredible and even if you aren't a fan of the Doors, this cd is great to listen to. What a relaxing mix of songs. Not to mention an incredible work by Winston. I wish Winston would do more covers of bands like this!"
Doors Impressionism
Jinkyu | 03/03/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Music by The Doors played only on piano? It sounded interesting to me, but to maintain the rhythm could be a challenge. Self-described "rural folk" pianist George Winston, who is more associated with the "New Age" genre, nevertheless does perform "Love Me Two Times" and "Love Her Madly" with solid worksmanship. For the most part, however, he takes a shot at the group's prettier compositions.
One of the talents of The Doors was to use fairly similar melodies and chord progressions on different songs and still produce a very distinctive song. "Love Street," from "Waiting for the Sun," was in some parts a variation on "The Crystal Ship" from the group's debut. Winston's piano shines on each, as he gives them a delicate, ponderous texture and still achieves the passion, particularly on "Ship." Winston embellishes the romantic overtones of "Wishful Sinful," seeming to state this underrated Doors' tune deserves more credit. On "Riders on the Storm," the mood is more like a moonlit lake than the Doors' dark highway.
I really enjoyed Winston's version of "Light My Fire." He negotiates the changes with fluidity, up to and down from the climaxes. He handles the dynamic tension well and adds some of his own toward the end. So often groups outdo the studio version of a song in their live performances, but the Doors never did this with "Light My Fire"--their improvisations in live versions of this classic could never match the original's perfect structure. That is why I enjoyed the version here so much: Winston basically follows the original, in all its majesty.
Winston attributes the Doors as a major influence, and their music inspired him. This was the impetus behind his solid effort here, without mere imitation. He and his piano left their own mark: Impressionistic paintings of Doors' tunes. Although I am reluctant to give 5 stars to cover CDs, I feel "Night Divides the Day" earned them all. The would-be title track (sort of) did not "make the scene," but Winston chases our pleasures here.