Search - Gathering :: Home

Kenneth W. (Eyesore) from TAUNTON, MA
Reviewed on 12/4/2007...

The Gathering -- if you didn't already know -- began their career as a gothic death band, then on their first full-length releases they progressed to a more doom-death style. Musically they were a slow, plodding doom metal band with a slight progressive lean similar to early Amorphis. The vocals were the typical death growls common to the genre until their second full-length. They released two demo EPs, An Imaginary Symphony and Moonlight Archer, that were more of a gothic death sound, heavier, faster and more aggressive. Then came the two full-length albums, Always... and Almost A Dance, under the prototypical doom-death style -- one album with death vocals, the other with clean, more doom-like vocals -- before seemingly reinventing themselves on their 1995 breakthrough album, Mandylion.

Musically not a whole lot changed, but with the removal of the male vocals (guttural and clean), and the addition of the godly female vocals of Anneke van Giersbergen, they sounded like a completely different band. Surely fans of the previous releases were dumbfounded, but it was hard to deny the sheer brilliance and beauty of Mandylion. Nighttime Birds followed with much of the same success. Then came yet another twist in the tale of The Gathering, that twist was the two-disc How The Measure A Planet?, an atmospheric rock masterpiece filled with ambience, keyboards, slow-moving guitar rhythms and a myriad of sounds far removed from the band's previous work and musically more in line with the legendary Pink Floyd; on this album Anneke's vocals were in full bloom, unlike previous albums where her voice worked within the music, on this album the music works within and throughout her majestic melodies. Then came If_Then_Else and again the band evolved, taking the qualities of How To Measure A Planet? and adding some heavier guitars and more driving rock sound. It's all relative, though, as it was still a far cry from Mandylion and Nighttime Birds. Skipping the experimental Black Light District EP, Souvenirs was next in line and was a close companion to If_Then_Else. Those hoping that these two heavier, more rock-oriented albums would lead them back to that Mandylion sound will have to continue waiting.

It seems that this band works in pairs: two gothic death demos, two doom-death albums, two gothic doom albums, the two-disc progressive rock opus, and then two atmospheric rock albums.

Welcome Home.

Once again The Gathering has taken their craft, dismantled it and put it back together using a different instructions manual. But like their previous albums, Home may sound a little different, at the end of the day they've not traveled too far. Sure, comparing this album to Always... would be like comparing Michael Jackson's face today to his face in the Seventies, but in the progression of the band this is just a slight nose job, noticeably different, but still a similar face. "Shortest Day" and "In Between" start the album and act as the bridge from Souvenirs with their more rock-oriented sound similar to that album. It isn't until after these two openers that you notice that slight change on the face of the band. The music box intro of "Alone" is shattered by a throbbing, almost-industrial/electronica-like circus beat accompanied by audio shifts and shapes first heard on the epic title track from the Black Light District EP, noisy and distorted on the surface, but with a lurking beauty beneath; truly one of the strangest, yet most amazing songs the band has written. "Waking Hour" and "Forgotten" are both soaring piano-based jewels that act as platforms for Anneke's stunning vocals, to not be moved by her voice is virtually impossible. "Fatigue" is a short atmospheric instrumental that leads into "A Noise Severe," a slight piano piece accompanied by slow, distorted guitars and quiet interludes.

"Solace" then walks through the door, all weird and misshapen and speaking a strange language, but somehow glowing with an eyebrow-raising intrigue. The song begins with Anneke speaking in a non-English tongue, and then enters a pounding, distorted drum beat and a vocal melody that simply shouldn't fit over such an odd rhythm. Guitars are present in the background, but go unnoticed over the drum beat and the vocals, which carry the song and make it a standout track that defies its own oddball nature. "Your Troubles Are Over" again focuses on that driving drum beat layered with those amazing vocal melodies, while "Box" and the acoustic-based "The Quiet One" follow a more mellow, lilting road. The album closes with "Home" and "Forgotten (Reprise)," the former being a slow, meandering piece that again revolves around the melodies of Anneke's vocals, the true album closer and a great one at that. The latter track, "Forgotten (Reprise)," adds a little ambient atmosphere where the piano was on the regular track earlier on the CD, a mellow, entrancing counterpoint.

The Gathering have never followed any rules, in fact they seem to make them up as they move steadily along this path they're constantly reshaping. Home is just another turn in the road for this band. Does it work every time? Damn near. The problem with this album is that after the first two tracks it's a fairly mellow affair. "Alone" and "Solace" add a nice dynamic to break up the monotony, but overall even at the album's heaviest point it's still a low-key collection of songs. The songs are great, but the album is the sort of album that will be enjoyed thoroughly in the right mood. Unfortunately that mood will likely not be as often as you'd hope. Certain tracks will hit home every time, but others will find themselves being skipped over far more often. Again, the songs are very good, something we've come to expect from this band, but I don't feel like they're the kind of songs that will standout each and every time you play the album. Home is a very solid release in a steady stream of other good to great to amazing releases, but it's definitely not their best album to date.

If this is home, I can live with that, because it's a nice place to be for a short period of time, and The Gathering will likely move again soon so I'm not too worried about the scenery getting old. Things are good for now.

Website: http://www.gathering.nl
MySpace: http://www.myspace.com/gatheringofficial

The Gathering - Last One With Anneke

Steven Sly | Kalamazoo, MI United States | 09/23/2008

(3 out of 5 stars)

""Home" would prove to be the last album for The Gathering with incredible vocalist Anneke Van Giersbergen at the helm. Shortly after the US tour in support of the album she announced that she was leaving the band. The album itself is another one that although I like it, does not exactly blow me away. It starts out very promising with the great song "Shortest Day". The next two "In Between" and "Alone" are both solid too, but things start to drag a bit as the album goes on. Anneke's vocals are pristine as ever, although seem somewhat restrained on this disc. The accompanying music is all decent, but again there is nothing here instrumentally that blows me away. The use of modern beats and electronics give the album a contemporary feel, and overall the sound is probably more radio friendly than some of the band's earlier works. How much you like this will depend on your personal taste. After seeing the band live on this tour I though a lot of this material came off a lot better in a live setting. I guess the bottom line is that I think this is a solid 3 star album, but I can't rate it much higher than that."

Always different....always great

B. Kemper | Madison, WI United States | 09/05/2007

(5 out of 5 stars)

"One way for a band to impress me is to grow and change over the years. I know there are those who would have liked The Gathering to stay stuck in their heavier-sounding period forever--and don't get me wrong, I love those discs too--but a one-trick pony band becomes boring pretty fast. This release is different, not only from earlier releases like Mandylion, but even from Souvenirs, and I think that's a good thing. In my view, this band has never put out a bad record, but a nice variety of very good ones. And I still maintain that Anneke's is the best voice in pop music today!"