Compared to 'Hub of Hubbard'
Robert Wade Cottingham | Dallas, TX | 07/02/2009
(3 out of 5 stars)
"This little review will probably help about six shoppers in the world,
but here's my experience ... 'The Hub of Hubbard', a studio album made around the same time as this live album 'Without a Song', is one of my top ten jazz albums. It is so burning and tight, and features Eddie Daniels on tenor as the other horn. Also, since it was on the MPS label, it sounded superb.
So, I was eager to hear this live concert with my hero Roland Hanna and the same drummer as 'Hub of Hubbard'. But, COMPARED TO 'The Hub of Hubbard', this album is a drag. It has all the pitfalls of a live album that remained unreleased for years: The mix is good but not great, and the set sounds kind of like 'just another night on the road'. There's a reason it was not rushed to press back when it was recorded.
If you love Freddie Hubbard, and love to hear everything he did, it's great.
But 'The Hub of Hubbard' is a much hotter, jazzier recording."
Blue Note unearths another gem.
attentive listener | Joysey | 06/14/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"First, Monk & Trane @ Carnegie, then Mingus @ Cornell, now this.
All I can say is, keep 'em coming. In 69', Hubb was brimming with confidence, ideas and youth, but the mostly standards program keeps things in the Milky Way, if not completely grounded on terra firma. The sonics are outstanding with the exception of some drop outs toward the end of Body and Soul. Hubb's tone has never sounded so strong, he was clearly a force of nature."
Amazing Freddie live recording !
Marek | USA | 06/03/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Just listened to it for the first time. Freddie truly delivers here and is at his peak ! Every track is amazing and rhythm section is great as well. This is a must have addition for any trumpet player or collector who loves Freddie Hubbard ! Rest in Peace Freddie and blow that trumpet together with Angels in Heaven."