Symphony No. 8 In B Minor, D. 759 'Unfinished': I. Allegro moderato
Symphony No. 8 In B Minor, D. 759 'Unfinished': II. Andante con moto
Symphony No. 9 In C, D. 944 'The Great': I. Andante - Allegro ma non troppo
Symphony No. 9 In C, D. 944 'The Great': II. Andante con moto
Symphony No. 9 In C, D. 944 'The Great': III. Scherzo (Allegro vivace) & Trio
Symphony No. 9 In C, D. 944 'The Great': IV. Finale (Allegro vivace)
Herbert von Karajan was on the record as saying that he did not believe Schubert's Ninth to be great music, which means that he only recorded it two or three times! Actually, his performance of this (and the "Unfinished") ... more »is a pretty good one, sincere and unaffected, with some excellent playing. These EMI recordings are preferable to the ones on DG, as they have more presence and a much more natural balance. In fact, Karajan does better with these pieces than with many that he claimed to love. Go figure. --David Hurwitz« less
Herbert von Karajan was on the record as saying that he did not believe Schubert's Ninth to be great music, which means that he only recorded it two or three times! Actually, his performance of this (and the "Unfinished") is a pretty good one, sincere and unaffected, with some excellent playing. These EMI recordings are preferable to the ones on DG, as they have more presence and a much more natural balance. In fact, Karajan does better with these pieces than with many that he claimed to love. Go figure. --David Hurwitz
"I've known Schubert's "Unfinished" Symphony since I was a little kid, and it's always been one of my favorite classical works. But until I bought this disc, I never really *experienced* it.
Karajan's interpretation is very different from most of the others in that it's much, *much* slower. Maintaining the enormous energy level required for this symphony over a significantly *longer* period of time by playing it slowly - and startlingly evenly - is an amazing feat, and Karajan's ability to draw this performance out of these musicians demonstrates his genius.
My experiences listening to this recording have been visceral, primal, and purely powerful. That's an awful lot to say for a piece of music."
Nice clean interpretation
Santa Fe Listener | 07/31/1999
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Karajan's this CD is one of the best interpretation of schubert's unfinished. It has depth and serenity of this symphony. His no.9 changed my view. I never like 'The great' But now I understand what Schubert intended. Especially trio part of third movement is so beautiful that I almost cried. You will never regret buying this CD."
HvK All the way!
Scott Giles | 07/28/2001
(4 out of 5 stars)
"These are tough, unsentimental readings of these symphonies. Unsentimental, yes...but not without feeling! Indeed, without the schmaltz, von Karajan brings out the sincere pathos of the music."
Karajan when he's merely proficient
Santa Fe Listener | Santa Fe, NM USA | 10/07/2005
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Karajan seemingly could conduct anything, and he has a Schubert Unfinished on DG, in somewhat scrappier sonics than this EMI remake, which sounds committed. Not this one, though. When he was uninvolved, Karajan still kept the proceedings efficient and crisp, and the Berlin Phil. executes all the notes with disciplined expertness.
But Schubert is a special composer, one whose charm is mixed with a fragile poignany, and these performances miss both those qualities. If you want to hear the Schubert 8th and 9th run thorugh the Karajan machinery, this is the CD for you. I should add that his whole Schubert cycle is similarly impersonal."