If you're gonna buy Extreme CDs, buy the whole catalog.
John S. Harris | Memphis, TN | 06/08/2002
(3 out of 5 stars)
"No compilation of Extreme songs, ESPECIALLY this one, can truly give you enough of a glimpse into the songwriting talent evident on Extreme's four studio albums. Skip this compilation and the other ones, and invest your money wisely in "Pornograffiti" and "III Sides to Every Story", the band's second and third discs, respectively. If you like what you hear (and you will), go ahead and round out your collection with their first and last releases, "Extreme" and "Waiting For The Punchline". All the records have their merits, but their second and third discs are masterpieces that deserve your immediate attention. This "Holehearted" collection is only a half-hearted attempt at capturing the true spirit of the band."