Overtly OK
Moses Alexander | Alabama, USA | 06/29/2001
(3 out of 5 stars)
"This recording is average...that's all I can say. There's just not that much heart in it. Its not that they aren't playing the right notes, or that its way off tempo or something, its just that its not robust like it should be. The strings are a little thin in places (especially in Symphony no. 8), and the brass is way too dry (especially in Sym no. 9...Fritz Reiner wrote the book on how brass was supposed to sound in this piece.) Basically, the performance lacks warmth, which is of the utmost importance in this piece. The piece is fantastic, absolutely one of my favorites, but there are so many great recordings of this, that this one just doesn't stack up against them...."