Textbook performance
paul best | new orleans | 11/27/2005
(3 out of 5 stars)
"I bought this cheaply priced 4 cd set on a recommendation by a music critic.
I figured many others didn't really work for me on a long term basis, Gieseking, Michelangeli, etc etc, no less than 10 others (refer to my review on Pommier's recording), and being cheap at 25/4 cds, I thought "why not"
Debussy is more than just technically mastering the keys. Play Beethoven with tech master, there a pianist can get away with it. But here in french impressionism, one must possess a tech mastery that gives CONFIDENCE to bring out the poetic subilities and flow of the music.
1) Jean Pommier
2) Pascal Roge
Are all you need
Thought I'd pull out this set one more time.
Listening to Prelude Bk1,#6, I wish for more pensive, darker feeling. Prelude Bk1,#7, abit of banging starts off.
As I say few individuals can play Debussy like Ericourt, but all in all fails to achieve a top 3 spot.
My 3 Star rating holds. Dec, 20, 2005.
EDIT:
UPDATES: Listening to the Etudes at the moment, Ericourt falls into the same difficulities as most pianists in the Etudes. What is the correct tempo to play these pieces in. Ericourt just rolls along and avoids missing the notes, but at the expense of bringing out any textures that are hidden within these gems.
Feel free to disagree and buy the set for yourself. :-)
"
A great colorist
Gabriel Cote | Sainte-Foy, Quebec Canada | 03/08/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I disagree completely with Mr. Best. I'm not too impressed by Gieseking, Michelangeli, Arrau, W. Haas, Francois, Crossley, Meyer, Rev, Zimerman, Richter, etc... or by Jean Pommier and Pascal (both are unidimensional). My favorite pianist in Debussy is Ivan Moravec (on Connoisseur Society/Supraphon and Vox).
I bought this 4 cd set last week and I love it. Ericourt is a great colorist who plays with intensity and, despite Mr. Best's opinion, he ''possess a tech mastery that gives CONFIDENCE to bring out the poetic subtleties and flow of the music''."