A fanstic Opera by one of our Greatest American Composers
Opera man | Florida | 02/08/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Carlisle Floyd has once again showed us all how a wonderful story about American life can be reenergized by a startlingly beautiful musical score. Its expansive underpinnings allow Bass Dean Peterson to explore all the possibilities of vocal interpretation in the character of Rucker Lattimore, which he does with great beauty. In the end of Act I with the sermon scene Peterson takes dramatic singing to a new height. Pat Racette again shows us the type of singing that takes our breath away, especially in the powerful and dramatic second act. And John Mcveigh shows us a dexterity in vocal and interpretive singing that few tenors share today. This is a long awaited, and very much appreciated addition to our American musical heritage and cudos must go again to Carlisle Floyd."
A marvelous experience
M. Temple | Houston, TX USA | 04/07/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I saw this production during its premiere at Houston Grand Opera -- what a wonderful opera this is. The recording, being a live one, has some infrequent stage noise that can distract you, but otherwise it is of great quality. Peterson, Racette and McVeigh all sing quite well, and the music is marvelous. One of my favorites is mezzo Judith Christin who sings the comic role of Effie Belle Tate with great zest. I would hope this opera enters the repetoire and more people get to see and hear it."
Americana at its lyrical best
libriarsque | Texas | 05/02/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Carlisle Floyd is a national treasure. Time and time again, he has proved to be a composer of American theater at its best, combining superb orchestration with beautiful libretti (mostly written by himself) and affecting vocal writing. That this is his first attempt at comedy in no way diminishes any of those powers.
Having been involved in the original stage production (of which this CD is a live recording), I can testify firsthand to Floyd's commitment to the singers and their needs; while his vocal writing can certainly be challenging, it is never unreasonable. This commitment results in music that is gratifying not only to the performers, but to the listeners as well; there is nothing that negatively assaults the ear or intellect, and the listener is thus left free to pay attention to the drama.
The cast could hardly be bettered. One only laments that there is no companion DVD, for the onstage chemistry, particularly between Peterson, Racette, and McVeigh was palpable and utterly moving. However, the CD affords us a more than satisfactory testament to their vocal characterizations. In all my years in the business, I can think of few more touching, tear-jerking moments than the end of the second act.
Floyd's treatment of the novel is something I don't feel qualified to comment on, as I have not read it, but I can say that his opera holds up on its own, even without previous acquaintance with the novel.
I highly recommend this CD."