Absolutely Superb
C. Greco | 11/19/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This two CD recording, replete with beautiful packaging and over two hours of gorgeous music, is arguably the best installment of the Opus 111 series of ten albums on Frederic Chopin. A comprehensive recording of Chopin's "Well-Tempered Clavier-esque" Etudes Op. 25 and Preludes Op. 28, as well as a beautiful recording of Chopin's "Marche Funebre" Sonata Op. 35, make this album a welcome, important addition to any classical music collection. The piano playing here is outstanding; as the Amazon review notes, Sokolov is a rare pianist who benefits from an acute feel for the music and comprehension of the composer's hypothecated intensions. Sokolov's playing -- in front of a live audience, no less -- is altogether brilliant here. In short, "France Vol. 4" is an essential set of recordings and a must-have. Get this album! You won't regret doing so."
Wow, unexpectedly terrific
Eric J. Wu | cambridge, ma USA | 02/04/2000
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I've heard 4 recordings of the Etudes (Ashkenazy, Pollini, Lortie, Sokolov). I probably like this one the best, though it only contains Op 25. One downside of it is the sound quality: at points it sounds like the pitch goes bad or something. The performance is stunning, you're surprised to hear that it is a live recording! In my opinion, this is the most exciting of the etude recordings I've heard. Ashkenazy has beautiful tone, but I never "felt" his technique, Pollini has great fingers but sometimes the playing seems reserved, this recording combines what I consider the best of both of those recordings. I liked the performance of the Sonata a lot as well, however I have only heard 1 recording of it and do not have as much to compare it with."