Widor - Excellent!
Art Griggs | Sausalito, CA United States | 03/15/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I was impressed with this recording of these two organ symphonies. The abiance of the cathedral is striking. Listening intently or just playing softly in the background, I have found this CD to to be a pleasant break from the jazz and rock music normally heard on my system."
Worth considering at the price, but there are some major cav
G.D. | Norway | 02/28/2010
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Christian von Blohn seems intent on giving us relatively no-fuss, straightforward readings of two of Widor's most popular organ symphonies - which is surely a good thing. Unfortunately his playing is marred by what sounds like rhythmic insecurity; the lack of a steady pulse in the music in fact makes it sound wearisome and undermines much of its effect - the playing sounds a little bit as if Blohn were playing after a metronome, but were lingering just a little bit too much at the beginning of every bar so that he constantly has to rush a little to catch up. Now, I don't want to exaggerate the problem - it doesn't completely undermine what are, apart from that, sensitive and considered performances, but it is a detraction nonetheless especially in the fifth symphony. The instrument he is using is fair enough but unremarkable; as for the sound quality, it sounds remarkably clear and good - but you soon discover that clarity has been obtained by suppressing the bass line, which is definitely not a good thing. Again, though, I don't want to sound too harsh - I did derive some enjoyment from these performances, and I guess the disc as a whole is worth considering at the price. But the caveats are undeniable."
Ear-opener Pipe Organ Music
Robbin R. Macdonald | Arizona | 08/10/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"The performace(s) and audio reproduction quality of this CD were incomparable. Better yet, Vol. 3 of this little series offers a couple more purchases to savor.
"