Lovely, but not idiomatic
DJ Rix | NJ USA | 11/12/2007
(4 out of 5 stars)
"These are lovely versions of the Ives Violin & Piano Sonatas, performed with poise & polish. I'd consider them "internationalist" performances. Wakabayashi is from Japan via Julliard. Wise studied with Aloys Kontarsky, who recorded Ives' 2nd Piano Sonata over 45 years ago. The problem is that these are not particularly idiomatic performances. Ives put a barn dance fiddler & a saloon pianist into these works, along with some raucous camp meeting singers, & performers need to find, understand, & bring those personalities out. So as this duo masters the purely technical demands of the pieces, clearly enjoying the challenges, something's missing. They're too polite. The two "conservative" Brahmsian Adagios of Sonata No. 3 come across beautifully. All four sonatas are great enough to support these smooth interpretations. There's also the bonuses of the Pre-First Violin Sonata & the reasonable price. But the top recommendation for performance plus price has to go to the Thompson / Waters recording for Naxos (that page on Amazon also has several comprehensive reviews). The over-priced Fulkerson / Shannon on Bridge has a fine reputation. Let's hope that Nonesuch reissues the venerable Zukofsky / Kalish versions, & that someone, someday, sees fit to locate & restore a classic Rafael Druian / John Simms recording on Mercury (which I'm lucky enough to have on vinyl in "reprocessed stereo"), in excellent 1950's mono & including Lou Harrison's outstanding liner notes. The more the merrier for these Charles Ives masterpieces."