Search - Schumann, Celibidache :: CELIBIDACHE / Münchner Philharmoniker - Schumann: Symphonies Nos. 3 & 4

Vintage Celibidache

Edwin Mahler | Florida, USA | 09/28/2005

(5 out of 5 stars)

"When one listens to an orchestral work led by Maestro Celibidache one expect the tempos to be idiosyncratic and even enigmatic. Thus, one is not surprised at the slow ripening and unfolding of the complex sonorities in these two monumental symphonies. I cannot recall being as aware of the nuances of sound and harmony in virtually any other recorded symphonic work with the possible exception of some of the versions of Mahler's 5th, and Sibelius' 5th Symphonies. One hears these Schumann Symphonies in a completely different, and might I add "wonderful" way. If you have the time and inclination, it would be of interest to compare Celi's interpretation of these symphonies with those of other orchestras led by equally famous Maestros. Musical tastes will vary of course, but I think you will quickly grasp why the realtive paucity of authorized and well recorded performances of music led by Celibidache are a loss to all of us. Enjoy."

Schumann as one doesn't hear it very often.

Edwin Mahler | 09/16/1999

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Celibidache's slow tempi were never more in evidence than in this recording. Still, I can't ever remember being more moved than I was listening to these works as played by the Munich Orchestra. The sound is indescribably delicious, the phrases long and intelligent. The best part is the transition from the 3rd and 4th movements of the fourth symphony, which probably transcends anything Schumann had in mind, but I could not care less. It is truly stunning music-making, the kind we don't get to hear very often these days."