An excellent historical compendium
Amberyl | Washington DC | 11/27/2002
(4 out of 5 stars)
"For fans of Joseph Szigeti, or for collectors of violin recordings, this collection will probably be a must-have. However, casual listeners should seek the specific works and violinists that they're interested in. Those who haven't heard Szigeti before may wish to sample a single disc of his playing, before investing this much money.Packaging-wise, the Andante collections lead the market -- solid covers, in-depth commentary content from the Groves Dictionary of Music, and glossy color pages. The CDs are slotted into envelopes built into the package, which makes it a bit hard to get them out and in without getting finger-grease on them, but this isn't too big a deal.The music itself is well-chosen out of Szigeti's discography, though I regret the omission of Szigeti's recording of Bartok's Romanian Dances with the composer at the piano (but it's available on the Biddulph label).Szigeti's playing doesn't sound especially antiquated to modern ears; indeed, he could be said to be the first of the "modern" violinists, despite the early 20th century vintage of these recordings. He's an intellectual, with thoughtful interpretations in a classicist vein, and these particular choices illustrate his violinistic capabilities quite broadly.My only real complaint is the quality of the sound. While these are high-quality remasterings, they still have that "digital" sound to them. If you have these recordings as 78s or analog LPs, you will not want this collection unless you're trying to avoid wear and tear on your records (and even if so, you may be better off just making a CD-R copy). There's a loss of warmth to the sound that is clearly audible when you compare these to the analog originals; what has been achieved in clarity is not, in my opinion, worth what has been lost in tonal quality. Alternative individual remasterings exist in some cases; for instance, I prefer the EMI CD of the Mendelssohn/Mozart No. 4/Prokofiev No. 1 concertos.Nevertheless, this collection is highly recommended to fans of the history of the violin, as well as, of course, Szigeti fans who do not yet own much of his music on CD. The elegant packaging makes for a nice gift item, too."