Splendid
David Saemann | 03/24/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This is the last release in Cristian Mandeal's generally wonderful survey of Brahms's Concertos, Symphonies, and German Requiem. All of them have featured finely honed, distinctive music making. The current CD is no exception. It was recorded a year after the other Symphonies in the cycle, in 1996, but features the same warm, beautifully detailed sound engineering. The Georges Enescu Bucharest Philharmonic is a real find as a Brahms orchestra. They play with a wonderful chamber music feel and beautiful tone quality at all volumes. Not that this is a laid back Brahms 4. In fact, Mandeal is quite impetuous at times, especially in the third movement, which almost could be described as headstrong. My favorite Brahms Fourths are the 1953 Bernstein and the Kurt Redel/Philharmonia Hungarica version, the latter one perhaps being out of print. But I was very happy to add Mandeal's to my collection, it being only slightly lesser in quality and certainly an individually stamped interpretation. The Hungarian Dances are full toned and exciting. Now that I have all of the Mandeal Brahms Symphonies in individual releases, I have no hesitation in advising listeners to buy the complete boxed set whenever it is cheaper than the single discs."