Loving
David Saemann | 03/10/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Cristian Mandeal is a splendid Brahmsian. I have his Brahms 1st, all the Concertos, and the German Requiem. Every one of these discs is rewarding. This CD of the 2nd Symphony is a major statement of the music. Under Mandeal, the Bucharest Philharmonic is a fine orchestra. The strings are beautifully blended if slightly undernourished. The brass are warm and not too loud. The wind soloists are perhaps not of international caliber individually, but they play together as a choir very appealingly. Mandeal's interpretation of the 2nd is very straightforward, without a lot of fussing over detail. Some of the tempos, such as the slow one for the second subject of the last movement, are a little different that I am used to hearing, but all of them are justifiable. The cumulative impact of the symphony is really strong, building to a thrilling conclusion. The Tragic Overture also is excellent, moody when need be but alternately crisp and propulsive. The sound engineering, apparently by a Rumanian team, is absolutely superb, clear, transparent, and full. Anyone looking to add a fine 2nd to his collection, and a bargain to boot, should be very satisfied with this disc."