Not highly recommended.
08/12/1999
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Once again, David Hurwitz (the Amazon reviewer) seems to have missed the mark: this is definitely not Karajan's best Brahms cycle. His best version of the first symphony is in the DG "Originals" series, coupled with Schumann's first symphony (both of which Mr. Hurwitz hates!). These recordings are very harsh on the ear--perhaps if they are digitally remastered, the performances will shine through more convincingly. But these digital recordings, as they are right now, are like a kick in the teeth! I'm a big fan of Karajan, so that's a major disappointment, particularly since the overtures are included in this set. Karajan was very involved in the technical aspects of his recordings, so I'm surprised at the poor quality. It goes to show that digital is not always the best. For instance, there is a crackling noise at the very opening of the first symphony. The loud parts are very murky, and the winds, although they can be heard, do not blend well with the strings. For the best digital versions, I would turn to Claudio Abbado, with the same orchestra. Daniel Barenboim's recordings with the Chicago Symphony are also pretty good. Or you can buy the works separately: Karajan (1964) #1, Solti #2, Abbado #3, and Barenboim #4."