Power and Fun
Beethoven Junkie | NYC | 07/16/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"If you already have the Zinman Beethoven Symphonies (1999 -- Arte Nova), this recording is not going to break any new ground. I'd be hard pressed to choose between these and Zinman's as they are very similar in interpretation. If you only have the typical mid 20th century interpretatons such as those of von Karajan or Szell, then these and the Zinman are really going to change how you hear Beethoven. They have a lot of dynamic punch and use the faster tempos of the HIP movement that are so popular now. After listening to these and the Zinman, the slower tempos actually sound sluggish, boring and just plain wrong. What these recordings do have is slightly better sound quality than the Zinman recordings. I would love to hear a full cycle, but unfortunately, to date Fey has only recorded these and Nos. 4 and 6. If you want a full cycle and at a bargain price, then go for the Zinman. If you like picking and choosing performances then these and Fey's recording of the 4 and 6 are certainly great choices for modern symphony orchestra performances."