A warm performance with well-judged tempos and tonal beauty
08/24/1999
(4 out of 5 stars)
"With the final three quartets of Opus 18 on this recording (Nos. 4-6), you get a lot of chamber music (over 75 minutes) on this CD. That could be good or bad, or both if we were presented with spotty renditions. Fortunately, the Brandis Quartet offers a consistently high-quality set of performances. The quartet had been together for 15 years when this 1993 recording was made. That time spent together shows in the harmony and sensitive interplay between the members. Thomas Brandis, the former concertmaster for the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra, leads a group colleagues from the BPO and the university where he teaches. The performances are cultured with tempos well-suited for music which Beethoven wrote after a decade of living in one of the 19th Century, European centers of urbanity, Vienna. But don't assume cultured means boring. Listen to the Allegro in the A major Quartet (No. 5) for some exciting and fancy bow-work. The buoyancy and charm of the Haydn-like C minor quartet (No. 4) comes through in this recording by Nimbus. The recording field for these pieces is crowded with the likes of the Quartetto Italiano's and the Talich Quartet's older recordings, and the more-recent entries by the Tokyo String and Emerson Quartets. The Brandis Quartet's performance represents thoughtful, unglamorous music-making that gives deference to the composer's genius. In a field of tough-choices, this is a very good one."