M. C. Colver | henderson, nv United States | 03/30/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This collection was given to me as a Christmas present, and at first I wasn't to sure the quality would be as high as the giver had hoped. But! I was so impressed by the recording quality of the first 8 symphonies and Missa Solemnis. The piano concertos and other pieces were alright, but nothing to get too excited about. The Ninth Sympony was also alright, but I already owned a far superior recording that I prefered listening to. As for the first 8 Symphonies I was pleased with their overall sound. At no point in any of the tracks was I confronted with poor playing, poor tempo, or anything usually found on budget labels. As for the MISSA SOLEMNIS, this is one of the BEST recordings of the mass that I've ever heard. It was recorded live by Rudolf Barshai, and I feel like it is a recording often overlooked. In historic form, Barshai uses a boys choir for the soprano and alto choral sections. The soloists sound great, but the orchestra sounds even better (along with the basses and the tenors!) Usually I would shy away from a live performance, but Beethoven's use of sheer volume eliminates any of the 'stray coughs' and 'rustling' associated with live performances. IF for nothing else, buy this set for the mass- even if only to give as a gift to a future or budding fine music lover."