Search - Ludwig van Beethoven, Stuttgart Piano Trio, Monika Leonhard :: Beethoven: Piano Trios, Vol. 1

Profound Early Beethoven

Christopher Smith | Atlanta, Georgia | 06/08/2001

(5 out of 5 stars)

"With the exception of the "Pathetique" sonata, Beethoven's very early work is often ignored, which is a great shame. Not only are his Opus 2 set of piano sonatas beautfully accomplished pieces that unmistakably establish Beethoven's unique voice, but these piano trios show complete mastery of a form that Mozart and Haydn had both successfully mined by the time Beethoven arrived in Vienna. Although these were Beethoven's first published pieces, it is easy to see how confident he already was in his powers, and in his belief that he could expand the boundaries of the classical forms he inherited. There are three Opus 1 trios in all, and the first two are included here. Of the three, the third in C minor (the same key as the revolutionary Pathetique sonata and the fifth symphony) is the one that signals Beethoven's readiness to move beyond the parameters established by his predecessors. Nevertheless, the two on this recording are marvellous in and of themselves, and show a willingness on Beethoven's part to fully engage each instrument (Mozart's piano trios really under-utilize the cello) in wide-ranging and dramatic dialogue. Both pieces are serene and expansive, and the slow movements of both are especially pleasing. These pieces aren't in the same league as the middle period "Ghost" Trio or the late period masterpiece, the "Archduke." However, in looking for a late-18th century comparison, which is when the Opus 1's were written, I see them as the equal of Mozart's piano quartets, which means they're a must have.As for the performances, I have long ceased to have any reservations about the chamber ensembles that perform for Naxos. You won't have any either once you hear this recording. The Stuttgart Piano Trio (who have also recorded the wonderful Schubert Trios for Naxos, which I have reviewed elsewhere) have been playing together for years, which is reflected in the easy give and take you can't help noticing, with no single player hogging the limelight. Buy this CD, and throw in the Opus 1, no. 3 for good measure. You'll be surprised that Beethoven was so good, so early."

A Desert Island CD

Mr. Allan K. Steel | Sydney, AUS | 02/03/2006

(5 out of 5 stars)

"This CD is wonderful.



Early Beethoven is full of neglected masterpieces and Opus 1 is no exception. I love all of these early piano trios. The finale of No. 1 in particular is wonderful in its energy and vitality.



Although I have several recordings of these trios, this is probably the best. The Stuttgart Trio performs wonderfully, and the recording quality is first class.



Definitely a Desert Island CD which I always love coming back to."