Stephen G Bowden | NC School of the Arts | 07/03/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This set actually came to me as a mistake, but at $50, there wasn't really any question as to whether I should keep it or not. I expected the sound quality to be horrible, the playing sloppy (characteristic to Schnabel), and the interpretations to be too rowdy for me.These sonatas were recorded throughout the 1930's, but I will not lie, you can absolutely not tell at all. There is no hiss, only a rather beautifully played piano.Schnabel keeps sonatas 1-27 crisp, clean and clear. The interpretations seem perfect, despite a few oddly chosen tempi. The late sonatas, I can not say the same. I am especially thrown over the edge by no. 28's fourth movement. The fantastic melody, one of my favorites, is ruined by Schnabel's playing. Also, in the Hammerklavier, the opening four bars are rubbish. Other than those two mistakes (in my opinion), this set is one of the best money can buy, and worlds ahead of any other complete set for only $50. The beauty of his playing is astounding, and the remastering is a stroke of genius.If you are looking desperately for the proper Beethoven piano sonata set, as I was for months, this is the one. I also looked into Wilhelm Kempff's, Alfred Brendel's, Richard Goode's, Daniel Barenboim's and Anton Kuerti's.Although it is a widely known fact that no set of these sonatas is perfect, this is as close as it comes. Do yourself a favor, buy this set. For $50, it is an unsurpassable bargain."
Recording Quality
R. C Lauther | Sparta, NJ USA | 08/05/2004
(3 out of 5 stars)
"The CD set is an excellent historical audio documentation of Schnabel's virtuosity. I was disapointed in the quality of the recording. I suppose I am spoiled with new technology but this is a great performance recorded on a CD with vinyl record technology in the 1930's, which it is. I have heard the Sonata cycle on the BBC Online archives by a Spanish pianist. The sound quality was much better via the web."