The Only Problem ...
Giordano Bruno | Wherever I am, I am. | 12/02/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"... with the Arcanto Quartet's performance of Bartok is that they've only recorded #s 5&6! This CD leaves me insanely eager for them to finish the job, to record the first four quartets even if it costs an arm and a leg to buy them all.
The six Bartok quartets are properly respected and often recorded. I have three sets on CDs, by the Takacs, the Emersons, and the Kronos. They all have merits, though I was more satisfied with the Kronos in live performance than on CD. The Takacs make the music brusque and forceful. The Emersons refine it, tune it better, shape the dynamics more eloquently. But the Arcanto Quartet steals the show, playing with ferocious energy, with a huge resonance especially on their lower passages, yet with honest exposed tuning - little vibrato, that is - and faultless unity of phrasing. This is a quartet built from the cello up, the cellist being Jean-Guihen Queyras. The Emersons have been described as "not rough enough". Frankly, I don't want Bartok to be 'rough' in the usual sense, but I do want Bartok to be 'gutsy'... or gusty, if you prefer. The Arcantos play Bartok as if he had just dismounted from a huge white horse and opened up a saddle-bag of brigand's melodies."
Best 5th and 6th ever.
Christopher Pickert | 12/05/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This version of the 5th quartet gets everything right: the music's the overall shape, its fire and color, and all of its details. The Arcanto Quartet has a way of projecting powerfully without it feeling forced or harried, which benefits this music very much. Then there is the sixth. This is the first time I have enjoyed it from end to end and really seen how wonderful it is (despite being so tragic). This disc is a keeper! Now I hope they do the 4th, and 3rd."