Cluytens comes away with a lot better than average
Santa Fe Listener | Santa Fe, NM USA | 11/20/2005
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I can't agree with the reviewer below that Andre Cluytens was a great conductor. He certainly had his chances to prove otherwise, being one of EMI's house favorites for French music in the 50s and 60s; most unusually for a French conductor, he made a Beethoven cycle with the Berlin Phil. (readily available on the used CD market and beloved by fans) and regularly conducted Wagner at Bayreuth. None of it really stuck; Cluytens was a good, reliable stick man with no special ideas.
The Great Condcutors series has done well by him, however. Perhaps becasue the bulk of his many recordings wee with EMi--the main source for this series--the compilers oculd pick and choose. CD 1 contains a lively Bizet Sym. in C (1953 mono), far from the most sparkling ever done but nice and in good sound. Even better is his Debussy Images (stereo 1963), which greatly benefits from the idiomatic playing of the Paris Conservatoire orchestra. It doesn't rival Boulez for detail and finesse, but that's not the point here. CD 1 ends the French trifecta with Ravel's La Valse with the Philharmonia (even better stereo, 1958) that exchanges impact for swoony atmospherics--no perfumed ironies allowed.
CD 2 mixes in a bit of German and Russian with the French. A 1957 Schumann Manfred Over. with the Berlin Phil. is respectful and clean. The major work on this CD is a live 1964 Symphonie fantastique from Tokyo, again with the Paris Conservatoire orchestra--a memorable souvenir in decent radio stereo. The Prelude to Act III of Lohengrin is unusual for featuring the Paris Opera orchestra; it's straightforward and full-sounding. Finally, we get 10 min. of the Coronation scene from boris Christoff's well-known EMI recording of Boris Godunov from 1962. It's cleanly Gallic rather than moodily Russian. The best part is Christoff's appearance and the real Kremlin bells rather than Cluytens' leadership. Overall, Clutens is well represented without surprises or any risk of inspiration. Four stars."