Le grand, majestic, orgue,
Enrique Romerales Espinosa | Madrid, Spain | 07/07/2008
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Unlike Widor or Vierné(not to mention Cesar Franck's works), Guilmant's symphonies/sonatas have been mostly neglected in the recordings, with the exception of his first sonata and some isolated movements (as the theatrical scherzo from sonata 5). A master of the first generation within the silver age of organ, the late XIX century Belgian-French tradition, his sonatas have not only historical value for prompting the origination of the symphonic organ composition, but they are music of very high quality: firstly, solid formal constructions, and secondly, but importantly, rich, inspired, elaborated, varied, even brilliant at times. It certainly is not music to everyone, but it is Real music.
Van Oosten version is both technically and artistically beyond reproach. Lofty, spacious, neither too quick nor too slow; always clear, deep and majestic, letting this grand music evolve as it deserves.
The Cavaillé-Coll organ at Saint-Rouen is a magnificent instrument perfectly tuned, colorful and ideal for this repertoire.
The recording (1988) sounds really well, clear, crisp, without much reverberation and keeping the almost inevitable distortion produced by the bass from the organ pedal at a minimum.
If you like organ music, and specially the French romantic school, this set is a must, to be the companion of Widor's Symphonies, Vierné's symphonies and Fantasy Pieces, etc. But if you are looking for hollowly brilliant, dramatic, "fireworks" or simply entertaining music, then forget about it."