Armstrong's hot 5 and hot 7
Jens Schnabel | 03/20/2009
(5 out of 5 stars)
"What can I say - it is Armstrong's groundbreaking period in Music history.
There was no band before, that played this way, making Armstrong a musical innovator. So simply for his awesome music (Gully Low Blues, Skid Dat De Dat, Cornet Chop Suey, Potatoe Head Blues, Melancholy Blues, the list goes on) 5 stars!
As for the sound quality - people keep arguing about this box set and the Columbia set, which I unfortunately have not heard. Those judgments ALWAYS depend on the sound equipment (mainly loudspeaker system) one set might sound better on one system as the other. Then again not quite as good on another system, while the other set sounds better, simply depending on the mix of each set and what frequencies each sound-system "favors"- generally I don't think there's too much of a difference in sound, to significantly make a difference, especially not with average Sound equipment. And don't forget "Modern" technology can only do so much with a single track recording - push it toward the mid, high or low (there's more to it, but you get the idea) - so go ahead and pick up this CD-Box set for yourself - you won't regret it - unless you're a sound maniac in which case you simply have to get both CD-sets.
J.S."
The Benchmark and the Rosetta Stone of Jazz
GB | Sebastopol, CA | 05/07/2010
(5 out of 5 stars)
"When I first heard these recordings I was stunned by the ferocity of the playing and the remarkable sound quality. I later heard the Columbia records releases and was appalled. I guess that Columbia has improved on their recordings but this company (JSP) really does something magical with old recordings. I primarily like jazz of the fifties and sixties but these recordings when you listen closely to the playing are every bit as modern as later bands. I am now a huge fan of Armstrong and these recordings are still my favorite. I can not believe the price on this box set, either. This is a steal. I was so inspired by the sound quality of these recordings and the JSP box sets of Joe VenutiThe New York Sessions 1926-1935/Eddi Lang and Jelly Roll Morton that I recently played an hour of music from the 1920's on my local radio show. I primarily used recordings from this fabulous label with a very heavy rotation of tracks from this amazing collection."